Unlock Higher Sales: Are Product Recommendations Worth the Hype?

Do Product Recommendations Really Work? A Look at What Store Owners are Saying

We've all seen them: "You Might Also Like," "Frequently Bought Together," those little product recommendation sections sprinkled across e-commerce sites. But do they *actually* work? Do they move the needle on conversion rates and average order values (AOV)? That's exactly what @simplecheckout brought up in a recent Shopify Community discussion, and the answers were pretty insightful.

The Big Question: Hype vs. Reality

The original poster, @simplecheckout, was trying to cut through the marketing fluff and get to the core of the matter: Are product recommendations just hype, or are they a legitimate way to boost sales? They specifically asked about experiences with "Recommended for you," "You may also like," and bundle/upsell strategies.

They shared that their initial conversations with other brands yielded mixed results, with some seeing little to no improvement. The question then becomes: was this due to low traffic, poor data, weak placement, ineffective testing, or is it just that recommendations aren't as impactful as other merchandising efforts?

Beyond Recommendations: Free Shipping Thresholds

Before diving deep into recommendations, @simplecheckout received a great suggestion from Emma_at_Trepoly about free shipping thresholds. You know, that little message that says, "You're $X away from FREE shipping!" Emma suggested testing raising that threshold *slightly* above your current AOV. The idea is to nudge customers to add just a bit more to their cart to qualify, thus increasing your AOV.

Making Recommendations Meaningful

Emma_at_Trepoly also touched upon something crucial: recommendations and personalization need to be *meaningful*. Slapping a generic "You May Also Like" section on your product page probably won't cut it. Consider A/B testing different wording and layouts to see what resonates with your audience. Think about what makes sense in the context of the product being viewed.

Bundling for the Win

Bundling products with a discount was another winning idea. Emma_at_Trepoly pointed out that if shipping one or two items costs roughly the same, offering a discount on an additional product can encourage customers to add more to their order without significantly increasing your expenses. It’s a win-win!

Key Takeaways and Actionable Steps

So, what can we glean from this community discussion? Here’s a breakdown of actionable steps you can take to improve your conversion rate and AOV:

  1. Optimize Your Free Shipping Threshold: Experiment with raising your free shipping threshold slightly above your current AOV and monitor the results.
  2. Personalize Recommendations: Ensure your recommendations are relevant to the products being viewed. Don't just throw up a generic list.
  3. A/B Test Everything: Test different wording, layouts, and recommendation types to see what works best for your audience.
  4. Embrace Bundling: Create product bundles with discounts to encourage customers to add more items to their cart.

Ultimately, the success of product recommendations hinges on relevance, testing, and a bit of creativity. Don't be afraid to experiment and see what resonates with your audience. What works for one store might not work for another, so continuous optimization is key.

Share:

Use cases

Explore use cases

Agencies, store owners, enterprise — find the migration path that fits.

Explore use cases